Dennis Forbes on Pragmatic Software Development   Subscribe to RSS


About the Author
Dennis Forbes is a Toronto-based software architect. While focused primarily on the .NET and SQL Server worlds, Dennis frequently ventures outside of this comfort zone into game development, Linux development, and image processing. He has been published in several industry magazines, has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal and has been interviewed by NPR.

He is a vice president and lead software architect at an innovative New York City hedge fund back-office services firm.

Dennis has been working on solutions for the financial, telecommunications, and power generation markets for over 13 years.


Recent Entries


The Feed Bag

 
Sunday, May 28 2006

We had the Cogeco Digital Home Phone service installed last week, and I thought it worthwhile to document for searchers who might be looking for information on this service.

As we already subscribed to Cogeco's high speed internet,  the installer basically came in and disconnected the Bell copper pair from the internal twisted-pair network at the demarcation, replaced the cable modem in my office with a new, bulky, VoIP-equipped modem (bulky because it includes a small UPS battery at keeps it running for 8 hours of power outage. Of course I could extend duration longer via an external UPS, which I was considering for the office anyways), and then ran a phone line from it to a nearby phone jack, thereby providing phone service in the traditional way on the other jacks in the home.

Installation was absolutely painless and quick, and the internet part of the equation is better than ever (download rates come in at just under 900KB/second. I was super happy when it was 150KB/s, then 300KB/s, then 600KB/s, then 750KB/s, and now this). 

The phone service is absolutely superb: There is "local" calling throughout the continental North America, around the clock, at no addtional charge, which is a huge feature, and the service includes caller display, voice mail, 3-way calling, and so on. Operations are almost identical to Bell (e.g. the voicemail system has largely the same controls), and voice quality is indistinguishable from a normal old phone line -- the quality is perfect, and there is no apparent latency (I was expecting a cell-phone like latency -- which leads to people not accustomed to cell phones talking over each other -- and was surprized that it doesn't seem to have it).

The technical information that I've seen is that Cogeco has dedicated channels specifically for voice, using QoS technologies to ensure that voice always gets priority, and there are no outages or hiccups because you're downloading the new bundle of Windows service packs.

I feel foolish that we've taken this long to sign up for this service. While I worked for Bell Canada for a while, and hugely respect many of the people who work there, I have no love lost for them as a customer. Personally I find their billing practices reprehensible (such as the continually change "First Rate" plan, the rewriting of prime-time, or the fact that they charge you as much as possible, but if you consider switching providers suddenly new discounted rates will appear. I have great distaste for that sort of "as much as the customer will bear" type of billing). We've been very satisfied Cogeco customers for almost five years now, and now they've grown from our internet, television (including digital and movie networks), to also being our phone provider.

Amazing how much service is being shipped down that coaxial cable. I remember the arguments years back, debating ADSL versus cable, when the naysayers were convinced that soon enough every cable modem user would suffer under tremendous overuse on the "shared" medium. I'm still a very happy customer.

[Given that people usually only bother posting negative reviews and impressions, I'll add the following statement: I received no consideration by Cogeco for posting this positive entry, and I'm not biased towards them in any way -- I don't own Cogeco stock, and I'm not friends or family with any of their employees or agents]

  Personal 

Reader Comments

Thanks very much for this review, Dennis! (I found you in a google search.) My two-year Bell contract expires later this month, and I've been plotting dumping them for the last two years. I've been delighted with Cogeco's internet service, and it's great to hear that they're continuing that tradition of excellent service with digital phone. I'm going to dig around a bit more, but I'm pretty sure I'll be switching later this month.
Jennifer Lackey @ 9/4/2006 9:05:42 AM
Ya just dont try calling anywhere else in the world like south america or europe and good luck getting them to call you,nice try buddy but do more research next time.....
micro man @ 9/11/2006 7:09:47 PM
The world has no lack of assholes.

In any case, AS MENTIONED, I've had nothing but good luck with their service. Regarding europe/south america -- See, I don't call either. It's not a problem. Maybe it's a problem for YOU, but go and set up your own angry page raging at the machine. And IF I DID, I'd use one of the countless calling cards that utilize a 1-800 number, getting the best of both worlds anyways.

Go shout insults from the peanut gallery somewhere else angryman.
Dennis Forbes @ 9/11/2006 8:01:41 PM
Thanks again, Dennis, for a great review, which prompted me to take a chance on Cogeco digital phone myself here in Oakville. Since I already have Cogeco cable and high-speed, the introductory deal was pretty sweet.

I was a bit leery about the whole concept after my experience with Primus Talk Broadband: Voice quality, latency, and connection stability left a lot to be desired.

However, after being hooked up for five days now, both my wife and I are quite pleased. Connections have been rock solid; voice quality is excellent. We noticed a bit of echoing on an overseas call, but this may have been a one-off anomaly; at any rate, this was quite minor.

The boosted internet speed with the new modem is certainly a welcome bonus!

Not only were "micro man's" comments nasty and unbalanced, they were also quite inaccurate and misleading. It's true that we can't dial direct overseas now, but Cogeco has partnered with a pre-paid phone card provider to offer PIN-free overseas access (and speed dialing) when the access number is dialed from registered phone numbers. For the number of such calls we make, this is quite acceptable. And the suggestion that overseas callers can't dial through to a Cogeco phone is absolute cr*p!

Virtually the only currently absent feature that we will miss is the ability to accept collect calls. With a globetrotting twenty-something daughter, we like to have this as a bottom-line emergency option.

All in all, a solid thumbs up so far.
David Nobel @ 10/17/2007 3:56:20 PM
Hi I'd like to share some of my experiences with cogeco digital service. First the installation was painless and quick. I wasn't told until during the installation that i would no longer be in the bell phone book - apparently if you aren't a customer they don't put you in the book. ok with me however then the technician told me that i couldn't get collect calls. no one bothered to mention that. ok i can live with that.

However I have had the misfortune of experiencing a lot of problems with my digital phone. First let me say i love the fact that i can call family and friends in NA 24/7 however i have found the quality is intermittently very poor. sometimes, but not always i have background chatter, dropped calls, echos and darth vadar type voices. I also have experienced not getting all my voice mails, having calls dropped in the middle of consversation; not always having overseas calls go through - calls made to me. I also sometimes lose my service even when there isn't a problem in the area. I could go on and on. and yet I persist with the digital phone, because most of the time it works and i enjoy making lots of long distance calls. I have complained numerous times to cogeco - oh the joys of going through all that just to get help However I put up with it, because as stated earlier my phone works most of the time. However I am starting to get frustrated. I was just wondering if anyone else has experienced these problems. I've had the service for over a year so my low promotion rate has gone up (not a lot) and basically my service has gone down. Anyone else having these kind of problems. would love to hear

I have asked for a supervisor or someone with tech, know how from cegco to address these problems i am waitng for them to return my call. any suggestions.
carolyn mccoy @ 3/12/2008 9:46:59 PM
Carolyn,

You can try to call the Office of the President at 905-333-7987. They will generally get back to you within 24 hours. It tends to escalate the issue but the correction can take time.

I have just moved to a new city and had Cogeco phone service installed. Cogeco has been granted a new exchange and has issued me a number however it seems that the number has not been registered with Bell. While I can make outgoing calls to all of North America they can not call me back. The problem has been going for 4 weeks now and I am calling the above number twice a week.

Good luck with your issues and I hope the number helps.

Colin
Colin M @ 3/26/2008 4:52:17 PM

Add Comment

Name *:

Email Address:

(your email address is not displayed)
Website:

Comment *:


Dennis Forbes