Tuesday, November 01 2005

Today's big announcement from Microsoft, among some other tidbits, was the demo and public release of a beta of Microsoft Live, which you can of course read Scoble busting a vein about. I would love to say that it's remarkable, but it doesn't seem to be - At first glance it barely differs from the whole Excite @ Home portal concept that hit the floor with a thud 6 years ago. It looks like Excite (@) Home + a greatly scaled down version of Konfabulator in a limited, IE-only, heavyweight shell.

Portals are dead, and if this is the great revolution Microsoft can deliver, then Microsoft truly is in serious trouble. Microsoft has done some amazing things, and they have a lot of amazing people, so when they're doing a supposedly huge strategy shift to take on Google it should be extraordinary. It shouldn't leave you searching around trying to find where the good stuff is hidden. Weak excuses that they "can't show the best stuff yet...you just wait!" rightfully raises the B.S. detectors of most grizzled software development vets (because we've used that lame excuse when we've under-delivered)

Of course, as is standard for these sorts of things, Microsoft is also trying to get the community to create the content via a cheap-labour contest (which Google has been a great exploiter of) - Expend the effort and trouble to add to their somewhat weak launch list of "gadgets" and you too could be entered into a draw to win an XBox 360! Woo! I'm always amazed at how cheap such firms can be about an element of their strategy that is so enormously critical.

Microsoft biggest announcement today was vapour, and "coming soon" betas. What a disaster (it isn't that it's a terrible solution that they've built, but rather that it's just so underwhelming coming from the largest, most powerful software company in the world. Expectations are so much higher, especially given the emphasis put on this strategy). I'll reiterate that 2006 won't be the year for Microsoft (and I'm a Microdroid by some accounts).

   

Reader Comments

"I'm always amazed at how cheap such firms can be about an element of their strategy that is so enormously critical."

Criminy, you ain't kidding. Wow, they're giving away ONE whole XBox 360? These guys are sitting on a huge pile of cash, they could afford to give _everybody who enters_ a 360!

(Not to mention that they'd make the money back when those people go buy games for their new toy)
Jason Lefkowitz @ 11/1/2005 9:20:50 PM
Microsoft has lost it. After all of the hype, in the past couple of weeks we've seen Microsoft release a couple of products expected a year or more ago, and this terribly under-delivering web app.
Hrumph @ 11/1/2005 9:40:13 PM
I agree, I was also very disappointed. I literally shaked my head in disbelief: a portal?! But then I did think that it is much, much better than Google's recent offerings. Also, people that are into this web 2.0 thing seem to like it: http://www.techcrunch.com/2005/11/01/windows-live-more-than-an-ajax-desktop/
lena @ 11/2/2005 4:00:53 AM
Thank you for the link lena - a very interesting take. One comment on that webpage that I would debate, though, was the suggestion that soon there will be "thousands" of gadgets - If history is any indication, there will be close to none.

Microsoft has had all sorts of these "we build the foundation and the community builds the framework" initiatives and they generally just don't do very well. Microsoft just isn't the sort of company that the small innovators want to help, and the professionals see zero revenue potential in many of Microsoft's plans.

Oooh, but we could win an xbox 360!
Dennis Forbes @ 11/2/2005 9:52:41 AM

Add Comment

Name *:

Email Address:

(your email address is not displayed)
Website:

Comment *:



About the Author
Dennis Forbes Dennis Forbes is a Toronto-based software architect. While focused primarily on the .NET and SQL Server worlds, Dennis frequently ventures outside of this comfort zone into game development and image processing. He has been published in several industry magazines, has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal and has been interviewed by NPR.

He is a vice president and lead software architect at an innovative New York City hedge fund back-office services firm.

Dennis has been working on solutions for the financial, telecommunications, and power generation markets for over 15 years.





 

Dennis Forbes